Young Alice Nelson

 lives in Lisbon, Maine. Alice graduated from South Lisbon High School in 1960. She is a waitress in a diner downtown, but has bigger plans for her life. She plans to leave town for Bangor and then ultimately go to New York City.

Jake meets Alice when he stops by the diner for a meal. He is astounded by how good the food tastes and compliments her. He eventually realizes that she is the Alice he knows in 2016, the jaded and cynical Vice Principal at the same school.

Trivia

 * The character was credited as "Waitress".
 * Paulette Sinclair portrays Alice as an older woman in 2016.